fame vs fortune

The other day, I randomly recalled this surprisingly meaningful conversation that I had with my sister when we were kids. I don’t remember how old I was, but it was definitely while we were both still in primary school (she’s only a year older than I am), and I’m almost willing to bet that I was less than 10 at the time. Basically, we were just kids.

To be honest, I don’t remember a whole lot about the conversation or how it came about (maybe we were at home listening to music?) but the general bones of the chat are still there in my mind. It all revolved around this one question: Would you rather be rich or famous?

I’m not sure why I suddenly thought of this conversation, or of this question – my memory can be a bit odd with what it wants to share with my conscious mind – but it made me stop and wonder if my answer has changed. I don’t think it has.

After having this random recollection, I went around asking a few friends what they thought of it. The overwhelming majority (i.e. everyone) immediately chose fortune over fame. This was the result I expected, but it was slightly disappointing nonetheless – I got the impression that people were just being really practical, or they had such a negative idea of what “fame” entailed that they chose fortune without hesitation. As such, I had to qualify the question by asking people to consider the ideal scenario of fame alongside the ideal scenario of wealth (because wealth has its drawbacks too).

In my mind, I thought of fame, in the positive sense, as being well-known, well-loved, and having people care about what you say and do. In regards to fortune, I suppose it’s about having secure finances and not having to worry about money. You can choose to be famous for whatever you want to be (but you cannot be rich), and you can be rich for whatever reason (provided you’re not also famous for it). I know it’s hard to get one without the other, but this is just a hypothetical scenario.

With these qualifying statements, everyone re-thought their response, but only one changed her answer. This made the overall result slightly less disappointing.

What I find interesting is that when my sister asked me this question all those years ago, I did not hesitate to choose fame. There were no qualifiers or conditions or careful definitions. I remember the answer just felt right. And, even now, I reckon I’d still choose fame. Well, that’s kind of what my gut instinct is telling me to choose.

But it doesn’t really make a great deal of sense for me because I am a very practical person, and I figure that money is the more practical choice. I’m also actually quite shy (although this probably depends on who you ask…) and, as a kid, I was really shy. Furthermore, I have no interest in celebrity gossip, and I don’t even follow any celebrities on any sort of social media. So why would I choose fame? Why would I still choose fame?

Having thought about this for a while, I think the answer is something to do with wanting to have an impact on people’s lives, or wanting to have some influence (or power, if you will) over other people and being able to make some sort of contribution in that way. I think that is why I chose fame – or at least part of the reason.

I’d be really interested to know if anyone else would choose fame as well, and their reasons for it. I have contemplated changing the question to include a time frame (e.g. If you could be rich or famous for one week (and then life returns to “normal”), which would you choose?) and I wonder if people’s answers would change then… I know mine wouldn’t.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “fame vs fortune

  1. I wouldn’t choose fame becase, having worked with more famous people I ever cared to meet, I now know that 1) it would bug me to be recognized in public 2) depending on your level of fame, you have to change your life around the fact that some of your life is lived in the public eye 3) it feeds insecurity. I have met famous people who were able to stay grounded and lived a pretty normal life, as intended by you and I, but I would still choose riches. There is so much that can be done with money, especially when it comes to benefiting humanity. Think of the projects you could fund!

    • That is always the main argument in favour of fortune, and the chance to support charity projects and make a real contribution is what makes me second guess my instinctive answer.

  2. I think I would choose fame as well. With so many people always listening to you, it would be so easy to send positive messages that would travel a long way. I’ve always wanted to help people fell better about themselves, and with fame it would be pretty easy to do that.

    • This comment puts a smile on my face. I feel like you’ve made the choice for the right reason. Always good to find likeminded people out in the world 🙂

  3. Pingback: scar | pistachio conspiracy #63

Please leave a comment (or two!) here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s